
MTD for VAT vs MTD for Income Tax: Key Differences Home Blogs...
You may be able to apply for an exemption from Making Tax Digital for Income Tax if your circumstances make digital record-keeping and electronic tax reporting unreasonable or impracticable. However, not everyone who finds MTD difficult qualifies, and some exemptions apply automatically without an application.
HMRC recognises digital exclusion arising from circumstances such as disability, health conditions, age-related difficulties, religious beliefs and lack of reasonable internet access. It also provides temporary exemptions for certain taxpayers with particular Self Assessment circumstances.
If you are required to join MTD but believe an exemption applies, it is important to establish the correct category, provide appropriate supporting information and apply before your mandatory start date.
This guide explains who qualifies, how to submit an MTD exemption application, what HMRC will consider and what happens if your request is refused.
Yes. HMRC allows eligible taxpayers to apply for an exemption from Making Tax Digital for Income Tax where they meet the relevant conditions.
An exemption may be appropriate if digital exclusion makes it unreasonable for you to use compatible software to maintain records, submit quarterly updates or complete your annual tax return.
Certain temporary exemptions may also be available because of information or claims included, or expected to be included, on specific Self Assessment supplementary pages.
Some exemptions are automatic, while others require an application to HMRC. You should check which category applies before making a request.
Where an exemption is granted, you do not have to comply with the relevant MTD digital obligations for the period covered.
However, you must continue meeting your ordinary Self Assessment tax return and record-keeping responsibilities.
HMRC distinguishes between automatic exemptions and exemptions that must be requested.
The exemptions can also be temporary or continue indefinitely unless the taxpayer’s circumstances change.
Exemption category | Application required? | General treatment |
Qualifying income below the applicable mandatory threshold | No | Outside mandatory MTD under the applicable income rules |
No National Insurance number before the relevant tax year | No | Automatic exemption under HMRC’s conditions |
Certain trusts and other specified entities | No | Automatic role-based exemption |
Certain taxpayers with specified supplementary pages or claims | Not necessarily | Automatic temporary or longer-term exemption |
Digital exclusion due to disability, health, age or location | Generally yes | Assessed individually |
Qualifying religious beliefs | Generally yes | Assessed individually |
Certain expected future supplementary-page claims | Yes | Application-based temporary or longer-term exemption |
An exemption should not be assumed solely because you are elderly, have limited computer experience or previously filed paper tax returns.
HMRC considers the actual circumstances and the applicable statutory conditions.
Digital exclusion means that using compatible software to maintain digital records, submit quarterly updates or complete the annual tax return is not reasonable in the taxpayer’s circumstances.
HMRC considers whether practical barriers prevent the individual from complying.
Potential reasons include:
HMRC evaluates applications individually.
The central question is not simply whether digital accounting is inconvenient, but whether requiring it would be unreasonable in the circumstances.

MTD for VAT vs MTD for Income Tax: Key Differences Home Blogs...

Does Making Tax Digital Mean Paying Income Tax Quarterly? Home Blogs Does...

How to Apply for a Making Tax Digital Exemption Home Blogs How...

Making Tax Digital Penalties: Late Filing, Points and Fines Home Blogs Making...

Free MTD Software vs Paid Software: Which Should You Choose? Home Blogs...

Making Tax Digital for Non-Resident Landlords: UK Rules Home Blogs Making Tax...
Yes. An older taxpayer may qualify where age-related circumstances make digital compliance unreasonable.
However, age alone does not automatically establish an exemption.
For example, a 78-year-old landlord who has never used a computer and cannot reasonably maintain digital records because of their circumstances may have grounds to apply.
By contrast, another taxpayer of the same age who routinely uses online banking, accounting software and digital communications may not qualify on age grounds alone.
HMRC considers the individual’s actual capabilities and circumstances.
Yes.
Disability or a health condition may support an application where it prevents reasonable use of digital systems.
The relevant issue is the practical effect on the taxpayer’s ability to comply.
For example, a person with a serious visual impairment may be unable to use ordinary digital accounting tools without assistance.
However, HMRC may consider whether accessible technology or an authorised agent can reasonably manage the obligations.
An application should explain the specific difficulties rather than relying solely on the existence of a diagnosis.
Potentially.
HMRC recognises circumstances where a person cannot obtain internet access at home or at their business because of their location and cannot reasonably access it elsewhere.
For example, someone operating a business from a remote rural location may face genuine connectivity barriers.
However, simply preferring not to have broadband or choosing not to use internet services will not necessarily establish digital exclusion.
The application should explain the available connectivity and why reasonable alternatives are not practical.
Yes.
HMRC recognises exemptions where an individual belongs to a practising religious society or order whose beliefs are incompatible with using electronic communications or keeping digital records.
The relevant conditions include the nature of those beliefs and the individual’s use of digital technology.
An exemption is not automatically available merely because a taxpayer expresses a personal preference against electronic reporting.
HMRC identifies several reasons that are insufficient on their own.
These include:
For example, a landlord who owns one property and considers cloud accounting unnecessarily expensive would not normally qualify for an exemption solely because of that cost.
Similarly, a sole trader who has always maintained handwritten records does not automatically qualify simply because they prefer their existing method.
An exemption application needs to demonstrate a qualifying inability or unreasonable difficulty, not merely a preference for avoiding MTD.
HMRC can nevertheless consider the overall circumstances where several practical difficulties arise together.
Yes. HMRC applies certain exemptions using information already held on its systems.
Where an automatic exemption applies, the taxpayer generally does not need to submit a separate application.
The main MTD entry thresholds are:
MTD commencement date | Relevant qualifying income |
6 April 2026 | More than £50,000 in 2024/25 |
6 April 2027 | More than £30,000 in 2025/26 |
6 April 2028 | More than £20,000 in 2026/27 |
A taxpayer who does not exceed the relevant entry threshold and has not already become subject to MTD will generally remain outside mandatory MTD on that basis.
However, a taxpayer already within the regime cannot necessarily opt out immediately because their income falls.
HMRC has separate rules governing when existing participants may leave MTD following reductions in qualifying income.
HMRC provides an automatic exemption where an individual does not have a National Insurance number before the beginning of the relevant tax year.
The position should be reconsidered if circumstances change.
HMRC identifies automatic role-based exemptions, including certain trusts filing SA900, non-resident companies filing SA700 and personal representatives acting for deceased individuals.
These exemptions do not necessarily exempt the same individual from MTD in respect of separate personal self-employment or rental income.
Automatic exemptions also exist for certain individuals whose relevant returns contain specified information, including particular Lloyd’s underwriting circumstances and qualifying legal arrangements for individuals unable to provide information to HMRC.
The conditions are specific and should be checked against HMRC’s current guidance.
HMRC introduced transitional exemptions for certain taxpayers whose 2024/25 Self Assessment returns contained specified claims or supplementary pages.
These taxpayers are automatically exempt from MTD for the 2026/27 tax year.
Relevant circumstances include:
These exemptions generally last until April 2027.
Where the individual’s qualifying income exceeds £30,000 for 2025/26, they may be required to use MTD from 6 April 2027.
A landlord living overseas reports £65,000 in gross UK rental income for 2024/25.
Their return includes SA109 because of their tax residence circumstances.
Although their income exceeds the initial £50,000 threshold, the relevant SA109 exemption means they are not required to use MTD for 2026/27.
If their qualifying income for 2025/26 exceeds £30,000, they may need to join from April 2027.
This is a temporary exemption, not a permanent exclusion.
Yes, where the relevant conditions are satisfied.
For example, you may reasonably expect to include SA109 in your 2025/26 or 2026/27 return, despite not including it in your 2024/25 return.
If the applicable conditions are met, you may apply for the temporary exemption covering 2026/27.
SA109 is used for several residence-related matters, including non-residence, dual residence, split-year treatment and certain international tax claims.
However, simply planning to include SA109 without a legitimate reason does not establish exemption eligibility.
HMRC expects a reasonable basis for the anticipated claim or supplementary page.
Similar application rules can apply to certain expected claims involving qualifying care relief, trust or estate income, and specified averaging relief circumstances.
Yes.
HMRC provides longer-term automatic exemptions for certain taxpayers whose 2024/25 returns contained specified information.
These include certain:
These exemptions are not necessarily permanent.
HMRC has stated that the mandatory timetable for some of these taxpayer categories will be confirmed subsequently.
Where the relevant information was not included in the 2024/25 return but is reasonably expected in a later specified return, an application may be necessary.
The particular exemption category and relevant commencement date should be established before applying.
HMRC introduced transitional exemptions for certain taxpayers whose 2024/25 Self Assessment returns contained specified claims or supplementary pages.
These taxpayers are automatically exempt from MTD for the 2026/27 tax year.
Relevant circumstances include:
These exemptions generally last until April 2027.
Where the individual’s qualifying income exceeds £30,000 for 2025/26, they may be required to use MTD from 6 April 2027.
HMRC recommends applying before the date you would otherwise be required to start using Making Tax Digital.
For digital exclusion applications, the current timetable is:
Mandatory MTD start date | When to apply |
6 April 2026 | Applications can be made now |
6 April 2027 | Applications can be made now |
6 April 2028 | Apply from summer 2027 onwards |
If you are due to join in April 2027 and believe digital exclusion applies, you can submit your application now.
There is no need to wait until April 2027.
Applying early gives HMRC time to review your circumstances and may reduce uncertainty over your reporting obligations.
If you have already entered MTD, you should continue complying while HMRC considers your exemption application.
HMRC currently requires exemption applications to be made by telephone or in writing.
The application process is not simply a checkbox within ordinary accounting software.
Start by checking whether your circumstances fall within an automatic exemption.
If an automatic exemption applies, a separate application may not be required.
If you believe you qualify because of digital exclusion or a relevant expected future supplementary-page claim, you may need to apply.
HMRC’s official guidance explains the categories and application requirements.
If applying for yourself, HMRC generally requires:
For digital exclusion applications, HMRC also requests information about:
If several exemption grounds apply, HMRC asks you to submit one application explaining each relevant ground.
You can apply by calling or writing to HMRC using the official Self Assessment contact details.
If you apply by letter, use an appropriate heading.
For a digital exclusion application:
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax — digitally excluded application
For another exemption:
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax — exemption application
The letter should explain your circumstances clearly and include the relevant information.
Avoid sending sensitive personal information to an unverified address or third-party website.
The application should focus on the actual practical difficulties and relevant exemption conditions.
For example, a digitally excluded applicant might explain that:
The explanation should be factual and supported where possible.
Avoid generic statements such as “I do not understand computers” without describing why compliance would be unreasonable.
HMRC reviews the application and may request additional information.
It then issues a written decision confirming whether the exemption has been accepted.
The decision should identify the applicable exemption and its duration.
Yes.
An authorised tax agent can apply on behalf of a client.
An accountant must have the appropriate HMRC authority and submit a separate application for each individual client.
The exemption remains based on the client’s personal circumstances rather than the accountant’s own preferences or administrative arrangements.
For example, an accountant may help an elderly landlord explain the difficulties they face with digital systems and provide relevant information to HMRC.
However, HMRC may consider whether the accountant can reasonably maintain the digital records and complete MTD submissions on the client’s behalf.
If an agent can manage the requirements through compatible software, an exemption may not be necessary.
This should be considered before making an application based solely on the taxpayer’s inability to use software personally.
Yes.
HMRC allows a friend or family member to apply on someone else’s behalf if they have the appropriate authorisation.
This may be useful where the taxpayer has difficulty communicating with HMRC or completing administrative tasks.
Authorisation can be arranged in writing or, in certain circumstances, by telephone with the taxpayer present to provide permission.
The person applying should understand the taxpayer’s actual circumstances and provide the necessary information accurately.
A family member’s involvement does not automatically establish the exemption.
HMRC still assesses whether the taxpayer meets the relevant conditions.
Being exempt from using MTD-compatible software for VAT does not always mean you are automatically exempt from MTD for Income Tax.
HMRC distinguishes the two regimes.
If HMRC previously granted you an MTD for VAT exemption because of digital exclusion, you should contact HMRC and provide the relevant details.
These can include:
Where the circumstances remain unchanged, HMRC says it can confirm that the Income Tax exemption also applies.
If your circumstances have changed, a separate application may be necessary.
An exemption from MTD for VAT arising solely because of an insolvency procedure does not automatically provide an exemption from MTD for Income Tax.
HMRC aims to respond within 28 calendar days of receiving an application.
However, the process may take longer if additional information is needed.
For example, HMRC may ask for further details about:
Where possible, provide a clear and complete explanation when applying to reduce unnecessary correspondence.
The 28-day period is HMRC’s stated aim, not a guaranteed decision deadline.
HMRC will issue a written decision explaining the exemption and how long it applies.
For example, the decision may confirm a temporary exemption until April 2027 or a digital exclusion exemption that continues while the relevant circumstances remain.
While exempt, you do not need to comply with the MTD digital obligations covered by the decision.
However, an MTD exemption does not remove the obligation to submit Self Assessment returns or pay Income Tax where required.
You must continue maintaining appropriate accounting records and supporting documents under the ordinary tax rules.
For taxpayers exempt during 2026/27, the applicable pre-existing Self Assessment penalty arrangements continue to be relevant.
The precise penalty treatment for later tax years depends on the applicable regime and circumstances.
HMRC will send a decision letter explaining why the application was refused.
If you disagree, you have the right to appeal.
The normal appeal deadline is 30 days from the date of HMRC’s decision letter.
The appeal must be made in writing and should explain why you disagree with HMRC’s conclusion.
You should also include relevant new information or evidence that supports your circumstances.
How to Appeal a Rejected MTD Exemption
For digital exclusion, HMRC specifies the heading:
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax — digitally excluded appeal
For another exemption category:
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax — exemption appeal
Send the appeal to the address provided in the decision letter.
If you require more time, contact HMRC using the appropriate Self Assessment or agent contact route.
An appeal should address the legal exemption criteria and any factual misunderstanding in HMRC’s original decision.
Simply repeating that you dislike digital accounting is unlikely to establish a successful appeal.
If you have already registered for MTD and subsequently apply because your circumstances have changed, HMRC instructs you to continue using MTD while waiting for its decision.
This means you should not stop maintaining digital records or submitting required updates merely because an exemption application has been made.
If you are approaching your mandatory start date and have not yet received a decision, seek clarification from HMRC about your obligations.
An application is not itself confirmation that an exemption has been granted.
You must also continue maintaining the ordinary records and supporting information required for Self Assessment.
Where an appeal is pending, the relevant reporting position should be checked carefully rather than assuming that all compliance obligations are suspended.
A common assumption is that if someone cannot personally use accounting software, they must apply for a digital exclusion exemption.
That is not necessarily correct.
HMRC specifically recognises that an accountant or authorised agent may be able to maintain digital records and submit information on the taxpayer’s behalf.
Consider two landlords.
Landlord A has limited computer skills but uses an accountant who maintains their rental records in compatible software and handles all submissions.
Although the landlord does not personally operate the software, the accountant may be able to meet the MTD requirements on their behalf.
An exemption may therefore be unnecessary.
Landlord B has substantial health-related difficulties and cannot reasonably participate in the digital reporting process, even after considering available assistance.
Their circumstances may support a digital exclusion application, depending on the facts.
The distinction is important.
The legal test concerns whether digital compliance is reasonable in the taxpayer’s circumstances, not simply whether the taxpayer personally knows how to use accounting software.
There are also practical issues around temporary exemptions.
For example, a non-resident landlord whose SA109 return created an automatic exemption for 2026/27 may still need to comply from April 2027.
Applying for an exemption that is already automatic, or assuming that temporary relief lasts indefinitely, can create unnecessary confusion.
The most effective approach is to establish:
Professional assistance can be valuable where the exemption conditions, tax residence circumstances or supporting evidence require careful consideration.
If you believe you cannot reasonably comply with Making Tax Digital, it is important to establish whether you qualify for an exemption before your reporting obligations become overdue.
Some exemptions are automatic, while others require a detailed explanation and supporting evidence.
Naail & Co Chartered Certified Accountants & Tax Advisors can assist with reviewing MTD eligibility, identifying relevant exemptions, preparing applications and dealing with HMRC correspondence.
Where an exemption is not available, we can also discuss whether suitable accounting software and professional bookkeeping support could provide a manageable compliance solution.
Learn more about our MTD for Income Tax accounting services.
Get in touch with Naail & Co to book your free initial consultation.
Book Your Free Initial Consultation
The free initial consultation is an introductory discussion about your requirements. Detailed exemption assessments, applications, appeals and professional tax advice are quoted separately.
Monday – Friday
9:00 am – 5:30 pm
You can apply by contacting HMRC by telephone or in writing using the official Self Assessment contact details. You will need to explain the exemption grounds, provide your identifying information and supply supporting details relevant to your circumstances.
Yes. Age-related circumstances may support digital exclusion where using compatible software is not reasonably practicable. However, there is no automatic MTD exemption based solely on reaching a particular age.
Potentially. A disability or health condition may qualify where it makes digital record-keeping or electronic reporting unreasonable in the individual’s circumstances. HMRC considers applications individually and may ask about available assistance.
Not simply on that basis. Being unfamiliar with computers or accounting software is not normally sufficient by itself. You must establish that the digital requirements are unreasonable in your particular circumstances.
Taxpayers with qualifying income at or below the relevant mandatory threshold generally do not need to join MTD on that basis. However, someone already within MTD may need to satisfy separate rules before leaving after income falls.
Yes. An authorised accountant can submit an exemption application for a client. However, HMRC will assess the taxpayer’s circumstances and may consider whether the accountant can manage digital reporting on their behalf.
HMRC aims to respond within 28 calendar days. It may take longer if further information is required. The decision will confirm whether the exemption is accepted and how long it applies.
Yes. You normally have 30 days from the date of HMRC’s decision letter to appeal. The appeal must be in writing and should explain why the decision is incorrect, supported by relevant information.
Yes, where you remain required to submit a tax return. An MTD exemption removes the relevant digital reporting obligations but does not automatically remove ordinary Self Assessment filing or payment responsibilities.
Yes. Naail & Co can review the relevant tax and reporting circumstances, help establish whether an exemption may apply and assist with an application or appeal under an agreed professional engagement.
MTD for VAT vs MTD for Income Tax: Key Differences Home Blogs MTD for VAT vs MTD for Income Tax:...
Does Making Tax Digital Mean Paying Income Tax Quarterly? Home Blogs Does Making Tax Digital Mean Paying Income Tax Quarterly?...
How to Apply for a Making Tax Digital Exemption Home Blogs How to Apply for a Making Tax Digital Exemption...
Subscribe to our newsletter to receive our weekly feed.
69-71 Lambeth Walk London SE11 6DX
Monday – Friday 9:00 am – 5:30 pm
Subscribe to our newsletter
Follow us
Download from
Services
DROP US A LINE
Copyright 2024 Naail & Co | Designed by Orion Global Consulting. | Naail & Co is the trading name of Naail & Co Ltd | Company registration number 08606377 | VAT registration number 170 3380 31